iPhone 16 Pro Max vs iPhone 17 Pro Max: is the older one worth buying?

Short answer: buy the iPhone 17 Pro Max if you want the current phone and can pay Apple’s $1,199 starting price. Buy a refurbished iPhone 16 Pro Max only when the saving is large and the battery condition is guaranteed: Apple’s own refurbished 256 GB units start at $929 (checked 16 October 2026), which is about $270 less than a new 17 Pro Max.

Both phones have a 6.9-inch OLED display. Specs and prices are from Apple. Battery figures are Apple’s video-playback tests.

How do they compare?

	iPhone 16 Pro Max	iPhone 17 Pro Max
Released	September 2024	September 2025
Display	6.9-inch OLED, up to 120Hz	6.9-inch OLED, up to 120Hz, up to 3000 nits outdoor
Weight	227 g	233 g
Video playback (Apple claim)	Up to 33 hours	Up to 39 hours
Apple price	Refurbished from $929 (256 GB)	From $1,199 (256 GB)

Sources: iPhone 16 Pro Max specs, iPhone 17 Pro Max specs, Apple refurbished listing, iPhone 17 Pro Max announcement.

When is the 17 Pro Max worth the extra money?

When you want longer rated battery life, the brighter outdoor display and a longer software support window. Apple rates the 17 Pro Max at up to 39 hours of video playback against 33 hours for the 16 Pro Max. That is a meaningful difference if you travel without easy charging.

When is a refurbished 16 Pro Max the better buy?

When the price gap is around $270 or more and Apple (or another reputable seller) guarantees battery health and a clear return policy. The phones are the same size class, so the feel in your hand will be very similar. If a private seller offers a 16 Pro Max near the price of a new 17, buy the newer one.

What should you check on any used or refurbished phone?

Battery health percentage, activation lock removed, storage size, carrier lock, scratches on the Ceramic Shield and whether Face ID works. Prefer sellers who state what was tested and how long you can return it.

FAQ

Is the iPhone 16 Pro Max still worth buying in 2026?

Yes, at a clear discount with a good battery. At or near the price of a new 17 Pro Max, no.

How much does the iPhone 17 Pro Max cost?

Apple’s US starting price is $1,199 for 256 GB.

Do both phones fit the same cases?

Case fit can differ even when the screen size is the same. Check the exact model number on the case listing.

Tools for this decision: How much phone storage do I need?, Upgrade or keep calculator.